Argument on the land ethic

In the larger field of agriculture I am less competent to speak, but there seem to be somewhat parallel cleavages. Moreover the farmer, by the very nature of his techniques, must modify the biota more radically than the forester or the wildlife manager.

Argument on the Land Ethic & Tragedy of the Commons Essay

The "interests" of the component organs can only be comprehended from the point of view of the interest of the organism. However, all these laws have been enacted only to protect the interests of other humans, and not to protect land.

Argument on the Land Ethic & Tragedy of the Commons Essay

Erosion leads to muddy rivers that foul surface drinking water supplies; one need go no further than the red rivers downstream from housing developments in the southeast to see that.

It tends to ignore, and thus eventually to eliminate, many elements in the land community that lack commercial value, but that are as far as we know essential to its healthy functioning. The Pueblo Indians settled the Southwest in pre-Colombian times, but they happened. Leopold would argue that we likewise need to develop ethical principles regarding our treatment of land, and a sense of land stewardship, to maintain the biological or ecological community in which we inevitably live.

In fact, a common argument in favor of industrial agriculture is that it is a good practice because it increases the benefits for humans; benefits such as food abundance and a drop in food prices. Finally, some critics have questioned whether Leopold's land ethic might require unacceptable interferences with nature in order to protect current, but transient, ecological balances.

Violence, in turn, varies with human population density; a dense population requires a more violent conversion. Accordingly, one cannot derive "oughts" from "is-es," values from facts, prescriptions from descriptions.

For instance, take our current welfare system.

Land ethic

Beyond this, scholars disagree about the extent to which Leopold rejected traditional human-centered approaches to the environment and how literally he intended his basic moral maxim to be applied. Is not this formula too easy to accomplish anything worth while.

Just how far will such education take us. For Group A the basic commodities are sport and meat; the yardsticks of production are ciphers of take in pheasants and trout. New Church Arguments Instrumental Arguments Starting at the most external level is the economic set of arguments used to promote a land ethic.

A native of Iowa, he received an M. All gains from density are subject to a law of diminishing returns. In western societies, land is owned. Brinser argued that white settlers brought with them "the seeds of a civilization which has grown by consuming the land, that is, a civilization which has used up the land in much the same way that a furnace burns coal.

Once the Florida Legislation approve the bill to drug test welfare recipients inthe American Civil Liberties Union ACLU filed suit to stop it and a federal judge issued a temporary injunction. There is nothing that the land would do for the land that would not be to its benefit.

During the three thousand years which have since elapsed, ethical criteria have been extended to many fields of conduct, with corresponding shrinkages - in those judged by expediency only.

Covering the land with buildings and parking lots prohibits influx of rainwater to renew groundwater supplies, and the resulting increased runoff of rainwater causes flooding far beyond what would result in a natural system. They are free to remove all trees, other plants, and animals, thus stripping the land of its ecosystem.

Theological Arguments ; 6: The farmer who clears the woods off a 75 percent slope, turns his cows into the clearing, and dumps its rainfall, rocks, and soil into the community creek, is still if otherwise decent a respected member of society.

Our formula in such cases is to relegate their conservation to government as refuges, monuments, or parks. Why should we place such high value on current ecological balances. Abraham knew exactly what the land was for: Certainly not the animals, of which we have already extirpated many of the largest and most beautiful species.

Choose Type of service. But first, just try this vision. Biotas seem to differ in their capacity. Consumed by an enthusiasm for reductive analysis, "logical positivists" such as A.

Environmental Ethics

Some large animals are lost; swampy forests have become meadows or plowland; many new plants and animals are introduced, some of which escape as pests; the remaining natives are greatly changed in distribution and abundance.

In short, the plant succession stared the course of history; the pioneer simply demonstrated, for good or ill, what successions inhered in the land. If the private owner were ecologically minded, he would be proud to be the custodian of a reasonable proportion of such areas, which add diversity and beauty to his farm and to his community.

In India, regions devoid of any sod-forming grass have been settled, apparently without wrecking the land, by the simple expedient of carrying the grass to the cow, rather than vice versa. The next section of this essay is: Thus, these affirming sentiments and the resulting motivation gives us a "stake" in protecting and preserving our natural environment -- a stake more fundamental and enduring than "enlightened self interest.

Structure means the characteristic numbers, as well as the characteristic kinds and functions, of the component species. The Land Ethic Revisited. In his essay "The Land Ethic", naturalist and conservationist Aldo Leopold 1 argued that American, if not global, society needed further ethical development to account for human treatment of land.

Leopold's argument began with ancient Greek and Hebrew notions of morality, and he pointed out that in ancient. In The Land Ethic, Leopold attempts to explain why people are so selfish in the use of their land.

Throughout history, people have been ruthlessly fighting each other for control of the most land possible, including forests, beaches, plains, fields, mountains and so on. Argument on the Land Ethic & Tragedy of the Commons Essay While Leopold discusses The Land Ethic as a community concept as if land is a living-breathing thing, one must remember the natural human behavior of selfishness - Argument on the Land Ethic & Tragedy of the Commons Essay introduction.

The Land ethic regards an anthropocentric (i.e., human-centered) ethic as an analog to "kidney-centrism" -- ultimately self-defeating, because it is a point of view that is focused on the level of the component, rather than the level of the whole. The Aldo Leopold Foundation was founded in with a mission to foster the land ethic through the legacy of Aldo Leopold, awakening an ecological conscience in people throughout the world.

An argument for ‘voluntary decency.’ “The Land Ethic” was the culmination of decades of thinking about conservation and, more broadly, about the .

Argument on the land ethic
Rated 0/5 based on 60 review
GEOL The Land Ethic